23 · The drink

Templates you can cook from

Formulas, not scripture. The classics are sturdy because the jobs are right.

13 min read

Learn these as structures. The bottle can change. The jobs should not, until you can feel why you’re breaking them. Ounces below assume a 1:1 syrup unless the line says rich. Taste, because your citrus and your proof will move the ridge.

Old fashioned
  • 2 oz whiskey, aged rum, or brandy
  • ¼ oz rich demerara syrup, or a barspoon if the spirit is already sweet with oak
  • 2 dashes aromatic bitters
  • Stir. Strain over a large cube, or build it there.
  • Express orange peel over the top.

Spirit, a little sweet, bitter, dilution, aroma. If you can’t taste the base spirit, you added too much sugar or the ice was too wet.

Martini
  • 2¼ oz London dry gin
  • ¾ oz dry vermouth
  • 1 dash orange bitters, optional
  • Stir until silky. Strain into a chilled small glass.
  • Lemon peel, expressed. An olive is a different drink — salt and brine — not a garnish swap.

Drier means less vermouth, not a moral victory. At a teaspoon of vermouth you are mostly drinking cold gin, which is fine if the gin deserves it and the glass is cold. Fridge the vermouth.

Manhattan
  • 2 oz rye
  • 1 oz sweet vermouth
  • 2 dashes aromatic bitters
  • Stir. Strain. Cherry if you want the fruit, not if the cherry is a brown candy.

A perfect Manhattan splits the vermouth between sweet and dry. That’s a lighter, more wooden drink. Bourbon in place of rye makes it rounder and sweeter; you may want a slightly drier pour of vermouth.

Daiquiri
  • 2 oz unsweetened rum
  • ¾ oz fresh lime
  • ¾ oz 1:1 cane syrup — or ½ oz rich 2:1
  • Shake. Fine strain. Up.

This is the sour template everything else in the family leans on. Rum, lime, sugar, cold, diluted. No blender, no canned juice. A lime coin on top is aroma. A sugar rim is a different, sweeter drink.

Whiskey sour
  • 2 oz whiskey
  • ¾ oz lemon
  • ¾ oz 1:1 syrup
  • Optional: ½ to ¾ oz egg white
  • Shake hard. Fine strain. Bitters on the foam if you used the white.

The egg is texture, not flavor. Without it, this is a daiquiri in different clothes. Lemon, not lime, is the usual acid because it gets along with oak.

Negroni
  • 1 oz gin
  • 1 oz sweet vermouth
  • 1 oz Campari, or another red bitter of that intensity
  • Stir. Orange peel.

Equal parts is a contract, not a shrine. If the bitter liqueur shouts the gin down, pull it back a barspoon before you add more gin out of panic. A boulevardier puts bourbon or rye where the gin was and suddenly has dessert gravity. Stir it; don’t shake the bitterness into a froth unless you have a reason.

Highball
  • 2 oz spirit
  • 4 to 5 oz very cold soda, or a ginger beer you actually like
  • A cold tall glass, ice to the top, soda last, one gentle lift.

The length is the point. The spirit should still be recognizable at the last sip. If it tastes like sparkling water, the pour was shy or the soda was warm. A whiskey highball is a real drink, not a compromise.

Tommy’s margarita
  • 2 oz blanco tequila
  • 1 oz lime
  • ½ oz agave nectar, loosened with a splash of water if it won’t pour
  • Shake. Strain. No orange liqueur.

Useful because it removes the curaçao. You taste agave and lime instead of orange perfume. A classic margarita puts orange liqueur back in and then you must re-check the sugar, because the liqueur brought its own.